Solidarity / Kenotic / Incarnational Atonement

~1900 AD · von Balthasar

A family of modern atonement theologies that locate the saving work of Christ primarily in the Incarnation itself rather than (or in addition to) the cross. The kenotic tradition (from Philippians 2:7, ‘he emptied himself’) emphasizes Christ’s self-emptying solidarity with human limitation, suffering, and death. Hans Urs von Balthasar (1905–1988) develops a profound theology of Holy Saturday — Christ’s descent into the hell of God-forsakenness, experiencing the full depth of human abandonment and desolation — as itself salvific. Jürgen Moltmann’s The Crucified God (1972) argues that the cross reveals a God who suffers with humanity, radically revising classical theism’s insistence on divine impassibility. James Cone’s Black theology identifies Christ’s solidarity with the lynching victims of American racism as the heart of the atonement. These approaches emphasize divine solidarity with human suffering over legal transaction, and have been particularly influential in liberation, feminist, and womanist theologies.